THE
POWER OF POSITIVE IMAGININGS
by
Merrill
Findlay for Imagine
The Future
presented at the Altona Sustainable Development
Congress
Altona Civic Centre, western Melbourne, July 26,
1994. First published in the Congress Papers, and
later adapted for Redreaming
the plains.
More
than a decade before I was born, Europe collapsed
into yet another 'tribal' war -- only twenty years
after the last 'war to end all wars'. Many of you
may still remember Hitler's armies marching into
Czechoslovakia and Lithuania, that deal he did with
Stalin, the invasion of Poland, Norway, Denmark,
the Netherlands and Belgium, and then on into France.
The
port city of Rotterdam, like many other cities,
towns and villages around the globe, was bombed
into a heap of rubble. The Dutch government
surrendered and Queen Wilhemina and her ministers
fled to Britain. Meanwhile, Dutch patriots
took their resistance to the invasion underground.
If you weren't there at the time, you've probably
at least heard stories about people eating
tulip bulbs to survive -- and of course, many
didn't. Survive that is. In all, an estimated
50 million people didn't survive this conflagration
-- but I only mention it because this was
what was happening in Fred Polak's world.
Fred
Polak was a sociologist who grew up in Rotterdam
and, like many people at the time, he was
desperately trying to understand the madness
he was experiencing all around him. As part
of this journey, he wrote a book called The
image of the future. (Around about the
time, incidentally, that the North American
poet, Archibald MacLeish, was writing the
Preamble to Unesco's constitution: Since
wars begin in the minds of men, it is in the
minds of men that the defences of peace must
be constructed.)
Polak's
book, The image of the future, was
about how we humans simultaneously live in
the present and in that Other Place, the future.
About how we imagine that mythic Other Place
to explain our present, and how our images
of that place, the future, 'act as magnets
on our behaviour in the present' to precipitate
social change.
The
image of the future was translated into
English in 1961 by a young scholar called
Elise Boulding, the woman who later developed
the concept of the 200 year present which
Richard Slaughter mentioned at this Congress
yesterday. As Elise Boulding explains:
At
the macrohistorical level, the rise and fall
of images of the future precede or accompany
the rise and fall of cultures. The rise and
fall effect comes because images of the future
are like time-bombs which explode and spend
their strength at certain points in history,
so that new ones must be created. .......
He (Polak) conceives of certain images as
having had unusual potency and containing
in fact, triple charges. Each explosion creates
a breach in time, a sharp discontinuity, by
producing a vision for the particular culture
in which the explosion takes place, of a totally
new possibility. The society then begins to
mobilise its energies for a response to that
vision.
Polak
sifted through western civilisation's images
of the future and found that in most of them,
that Other Place was described as somewhere
positive where many of the problems of the
present had been solved. It was a place for
people to look forward to. Polak suggests
that these positive visions were what mobilised
Europe towards those great periods of social
transformation we now call 'the Renaissance',
'the Reformation', 'the Enlightenment'. And
in more down to earth terms, such images of
a better world mobilised us towards the abolition
of slavery and child labour, the emancipation
of women, parliamentary democracy, universal
suffrage, the eight hour day ... all those
milestones that we here now hold sacred, but
which were once considered by conservative
forces, to be 'impossible'.
Brave
new world of the twentieth century
Then
came the twentieth century and the future
changed. That Other Place we live in simultaneously
with the present became Aldous Huxley's Brave
new world (published in 1932) or George
Orwell's 1984 (published, of course,
in 1948). A scientifically rational place,
more totalitarian even than Plato's imagined
'Republic'. From the middle of the twentieth
century our future, that Other Place we live
in, had become a mushroom cloud, a Silent
Spring, or Coca Cola consumerism.
Soon
we had books like Jonathan Schell's The
fate of the earth published in 1982. Just
looking at it is enough to get the message:
a cover in full funeral black relieved only
by the name of the book in small white print.
The publisher's blurb says:
At
present most if us do nothing. We look away.
We remain calm. We are silent. We take refuge
in the hope that the holocaust won't happen,
and turn back to our individual concerns.
We deny the truth that is all around us. Indifferent
to the future of our kind, we grow indifferent
to one another. We drift apart. We grow cold.
We drowse our way toward the end of the world
...
Some
years after The fate of the earth was
published, I was asked by the organisers of
the United Nations pavilion at Brisbane's
Expo, to co-judge a children's art competition.
To look at hundreds of images, songs and poems
by young people about making the world a better
place. There was this drawing by a young boy:
I can still see it. He'd divided his page
in half: a bad world and a better one. The
bad one was easy and he drew it in meticulous
detail. Explosions, fire, war ships, tanks,
destruction. (Or that's how I remember it.)
The world he saw each night on TV or down
at the pinball parlour or in his comic books.
The present-day world of his deepest fears.
On
the other half of the page, a better world.
His prefered future. A figure sitting alone
on the beach. No detail. No content.
I'd
read dozens of research papers about children's
perceptions of the future, about their feelings
of hopelessness and despair, but I must say
these images shocked me. There were dozens
of them scattered across the table, young
people's representations of bad or present
worlds, beautifully drawn. Of cities turned
to ashes, forests to skeletons, fertile lands
to dust, once clear rivers to gutters. And
'better worlds' of lolly water cliches: beaches,
rainbows, sunshine, flowers, trees. Cute houses
with smoke rising from chimneys. Contented
cows grazing in green paddocks.
These
kids had searched their culture's collective
imagination for that Other Place and found
only pretty tourist post cards. Or worse,
catastrophes. To my inexperienced eye, they
had no hopes, no dreams, it seemed, of a world
that was qualitatively better than this, and
no tools with which they could think through
what that kind of world might look or feel
like, let alone the complex changes that are
required to make such a world real. If the
images of the future they were being exposed
to showed a Mad Max dystopia of violence,
species extinction and nuclear holocaust what
else could you expect? And if Fred Polak's
theories about social change were correct,
what sort of future were these kids being
drawn towards, when the future inside their
heads was just more of the present, or worse?
Well,
that was the Eighties. But it seems many people
in many different places were as concerned
as I was about what was happening to our planet,
and to our collective imaginings. In every
corner of the world, individuals and groups
were modestly creating new images of the future,
new possibilities to replace the doom and
gloom scenarios of the present and the recent
past. That's why you and I are here together
in this conference room today: to report that
despite the evidence from the present all
around us still, those old pictures of the
end of the world are WRONG. Because inside
our heads, we are building a new reality.
And we're calling it is a 'sustainable society'.
In
our imaginations many of us have already cleaned
up all the mess from the last few hundred
years. We've protected the habitats of all
the other species we share the planet with.
We've stabilised our global population. We've
redistributed our wealth more equitably. We've
designed and built our human communities so
each one of us can enjoy a richer and more
fulfilling life -- without compromising the
ability of future generations to enjoy rich
and fulfilling lives too. The mushroom cloud
has dissipated. The Silent Spring has burst
into song. The Greenhouse is back in nature's
hands. The ozone hole has closed. And Mad
Max and his mates are growing their own ah,
recreational herbs in the community garden
down the street and driving cute little hydrogen
powered numbers to visit their mums.
These
new images of the future are dragging us all
-- some of us admittedly still kicking and
screaming -- into a new reality. What we're
talking about at this Congress, is the process
of its becoming. In that process, the image
is shifting and evolving, but it still has
that magnetic force. The power to transform
the present.
Imagining
a sustainable Altona
But
let's just put a little flesh onto the bones
of this future world -- as a kind of summary
of what we've been discussing these last few
days.
We
have up to another million people living west
of the Yarra now and this basaltic plain is
one of the major production centres of the
Pacific Rim -- though if you still think in
terms of those old chimney stacks and pipes
spewing out 'externalities', you'd never know,
because it's all closed system production
now. Hardly any emissions. Any 'waste' you
create in one manufacturing process, you use
as as a raw resource for another. Even our
sewage is finally acknowledged as one of our
most valuable raw resources.
Of
course most of our energy is from renewables
in this sustainable future. A range of new
technologies and improvements on old ones
has been developed like you wouldn't have
been able to even conceive in the 1990s. Some
are smaller generating units that feed excess
energy into the grid, but most are self contained
processes designed to power individual communities
or buildings. Per capita energy consumption
has dropped by over 90% compared to 1990 consumption,
in part because of good passive solar design,
general energy efficiency, and very importantly,
the assistance regional authorities have given
in retrofitting older buildings with new insulating
materials and energy generating technologies
like solar-chlorophyl roofing tiles.
The
integrated and consultative approach to planning
that was instituted in the mid 1990s has meant
that in this region, the waste management,
transport, energy, and water systems have
been relatively painlessly transformed to
serve the needs of the region's people in
ways that are more ecologically benign than
they ever were in the past. We locals are
particularly proud of our rapid mass transit
services and our waste collecting, sorting
and composting units, for example.
People
want much more than good public transport,
efficient waste management, clean water and
power, however. We want to live in communities
that guarantee us rich personal lives. This
demand for diversity, complexity and intimacy
in community life on top of all the environmental
and aesthetic concerns presented our older
urban planners, architects and engineers with
challenges they had never been forced to consider
before. But they coped!
Once
the new, more environmentally sensitive production
processes emerged, the demography of the region
changed extraordinarily quickly. We have a
highly educated, highly skilled population
living in this region now. People are choosing
to live here because it provides them with
a very high quality of life. They are also
choosing to continue their education locally
at the various live campuses of Victoria University
-- which is now one of the most progressive
learning institutions in the world. It achieved
this reputation because, unburdened by a long
tradition, it was able to innovate rapidly
to meet the needs of the new century.
We've
also redefined our old ideas of 'work' in
the last few decades. It was obvious to anyone
who had the eyes to see that people wanted
much more from life than a 'job' and 'a wage'.
So we've developed systems to redistribute
our collective wealth in ways that are more
affirming and empowering and equitable. We've
cured those old social diseases of 'unemployment'
and youth alienation, and our policies to
nurture social diversity within larger communities
mean that many of the old social tensions
have dissipated. Without those our society
is now much more socially cohesive, and therefore
more sustainable. Our political structures
reflect this changed thinking: they are more
democratic and more representative of the
whole population than they used to be.
Despite
the regional population growth and industrial
development, we've consciously preserved and
enhanced the most significant features in
our natural environment. Those once contaminated
streams are now freshwater havens for all
kinds of indigenous species, for example,
and the natural wetlands, thousands of hectares
of them, have become, in a sense, the region's
soul. You could also say there's been a spiritual
renaissance here. Young people from this bioregion
are now making pilgrimages to other parts
of the world to help heal the damage done
to the planet over the last few hundred years
-- because they say they feel a spiritual
bond with the earth. They feel part of nature
not separate from it, and they see themselves
as Earth's custodians. It's an identity that
transcends old nationalistic, class and religious
divisions, and it is a powerful uniting force
in the world.
Well,
I could go on and on. Some of these things
we've talked about at this Congress, some
of them have been conspicuously absent from
the discussion so far. And of necessity, people
are still talking about parts of the picture
rather than wholes. But as I've tried to illustrate,
the parts do fit together into a bigger, more
integrated image.
The
future I've just described is of course, very
subjective: each of you will, I'm sure, fit
the pieces together in different ways according
to your own personal biases and knowledge
bases. But what's important is that now we
have a future that makes you want to be there.
An Other Place to live in simultaneously with
the present. We can imagine it, we want it,
we can discuss it -- and now we can create
it. A sustainable society here on this coastal
plain between the Yarra River and Geelong,
here on this planet Earth.
We
all live in Altona
I
don't know how many of you are familiar with
Percy Shelley, the English Romantic poet.
He was born in 1792 just after the French
Revolution, and drowned in Italy thirty years
later when Europe was beginning to industrialize.
(Faraday was experimenting with that hitherto
unimaginable contraption called an electric
motor, for example.)
In
Shelley's life time the great collective dreams
were liberalism and nationalism, the social forces
that freed much of Europe from despotism, and created
the nation state as we know it now. It was the Greeks
who were fighting for independence when Shelley
was around, and their struggles captured the imagination
of young people right across Europe. People like
Byron and Victor Hugo, and of course, young Shelley
himself. And it was Shelley who articulated what
so many people around the western world were feeling:
'We are all Greeks' he said. Over a century later,
at the height of the Cold War, John F. Kennedy expressed
similar sentiments: Ich bin ein Berliner, Kennedy
said -- I am a citizen of Berlin - with a nod to
the Roman orator, Cicero.
Well,
I'm no Byron or Shelley, Cicero or Kennedy, but
to me, what you people are doing here is very important
for us all. Sustainability is THE issue for the
twenty first century. We need you to make this future
you are beginning to imagine, that we're all beginning
to imagine -- we need you to make it real. The future
of us all depends on it. Because, in the most deeply
and globally poetic sense, we are all of us now,
citizens of this bioregion. We, all of us, live
in Altona. We are all Altonans.
First
published on-line 1995. Re-published 2003. Modified
26 July 2004. Revised 8 August, 2007.
Copyright
Merrill Findlay 1994